Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]



Welcome to the forums of the Undead Dominion of Lazarus. We hope you enjoy your visit.

You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.

Join our community!

If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features

Username:   Password:
Image hosting by Photobucket
  • Pages:
  • 1
[PROPOSAL] Security Act
Topic Started: Jul 14 2017, 04:33 PM (238 Views)
Amerion
Member Avatar
Star Destroyer
Security Act - click to view


Why should we consider this Act?

Currently, there are a number of laws which is not consistent with one another in language and structure. This Act standardises these Acts.

More importantly, it consolidates our laws into one easy to read law. The intention is for Lazarus' legal code to have chapters. So, if you were interested in looking at what the law is on security, you would only have to look at the Security Act rather than look through multiple ones.

The goal is to have a few chapters of laws; and this Act will form one of them.

I hope you will find this beneficial and support it. Please feel free to write down any feedback you may have ^_^

What does the Act do?

The Act combines two acts, the Grand Advisor Act and the Persona non grata Act; and includes a section specifying the line of successions.

Point-by-point, the Security Act:


  1. Line of Succesion:

    Cosmic Council


    • If the office of Convenor be vacated, the Deputy Convenor shall act as Acting Convenor until a special election has concluded.
    • If the office of Deputy Convenor be vacated, the Convenor may appoint a new Deputy Convenor.

    Diocesan


    • If the office of Sovereign be vacated, the Defender of the Realm (DotR) shall assume the office of Sovereign for the remainder of the term.
    • If the office of DotR be vacated, a special election shall be held.
    • If the office of an Archbishop is vacated, the Sovereign may delegate a member of the Archdiocese to serve as Acting Archbishop until a confirmation vote for the Archbishop has concluded.

    Celestial Inquisitorial Court


    • If the office of Holy Prelate be vacated, the Court shall choose a new Holy Prelate.
    • If the office of Prelate be vacated, a confirmation vote shall be held.

    World Assembly Delegacy


    • If the office of Sovereign/Delegate be vacated, the DotR/Vice Delegateshall assume the Delegacy for the remainder of the term.
    • If the offices of Sovereign and DotR be vacated, the Delegacy shall devolve in accordence with the Line of Succesion for the Vanguard.

    Vanguard


    • The Sovereign shall list the Line of Succession for the Vanguard and may make changes at any time. The Line needs to be confirmed by the Cosmic Council

  2. Vanguard:


    • There shall be seven Guardians. The Sovereign and DotR are among them.
    • A Councillor who meets the prerequsites shall apply to the Vanguard. The Counsil shall decide on the application through the appropriate process.

  3. Persona non grata:
    • In emergency situations, the Vanguard may declare a person a Persona non grata.
    • The Cosmic Council may vote to uphold this classification if it's a non-citizen but it must vote if it is a citizen.
Edited by Amerion, Jul 17 2017, 08:17 AM.
Mini Profile Top
 
Doperland
Member Avatar
Everybody's favorite Dictatorship
I do approve simplifying and condensing our laws. I don't see any issues either but then I might just be missing things. Good work.
Mini Profile Top
 
Kanglia
No Avatar

Looks great, it's a great job of condensing down laws & simplifying them in layman's terms without losing it's legal edge. I approve of the work in it's entirety, great job!
Mini Profile Top
 
The13th
Member Avatar
Guy in the Public Eye
I like it a lot! But- I did notice one thing. If there is more than one Deputy Convenor, who would fill the spot of Convenor? Would the Deputies work that out among themselves, does the Convenor pick, or what else happens there?

Anyways, nice work for sure! :)

*I do think I read somewhere that the Convenor does pick one of the Deputies to fill in the role but I don't exactly remember
Edited by The13th, Jul 14 2017, 05:48 PM.
Mini Profile Top
 
Aumelodia
Member Avatar
🌺 His Divine Eminence
The13th
Jul 14 2017, 05:47 PM
I like it a lot! But- I did notice one thing. If there is more than one Deputy Convenor, who would fill the spot of Convenor? Would the Deputies work that out among themselves, does the Convenor pick, or what else happens there?

Anyways, nice work for sure! :)

*I do think I read somewhere that the Convenor does pick one of the Deputies to fill in the role but I don't exactly remember
According to the Legislative Procedures Act, the Convenor is supposed to rank his/her deputies:
Legislative Procedures Act
 
6: Deputies and Vacancies
(1) The Speaker shall designate a number of citizens as deputies to assist in the administration of the Legislature.
(2) The Speaker shall rank these deputies. If the Speaker is absent or unable or to fulfill their duties, the highest ranked deputy available shall assume the responsibilities of the Speaker.

To clarify that, then, I suggest changing the Security Act proposal:
Security Act
Line of Succession - Cosmic Council
Cosmic Council

(1) Should the office of the Convenor be vacated; a Deputy Convenor the highest-ranked Deputy Convenor shall serve as Acting-Convenor until a Special Election for the position has concluded.


This line I find unnecessary:

Security Act
Line of Succession - Cosmic Council
(2) Should the office of the Deputy Convenor be vacated; the Convenor may appoint a Councillor to serve as Deputy Convenor.

There is no "office of the Deputy Convenor" in the sense that the Convenor may have as many or as few deputies as he/she wishes; so there is never a 'vacancy' or a need to 'appoint a new Deputy Convenor'. The Convenor may appoint deputies or remove them whenever he/she wishes :P

I also find this problematic:

Security Act
Line of Succession - Celestial Inquisitorial Court
(2) Should the office of a Prelate be vacated; a confirmation vote shall be held.

Once again, the Court does not have a fixed number so what a 'vacancy' means is unclear in this case. It could be interpreted to mean that any time a prelate resigns/is removed, a new one must be appointed.

Additionally-- is the Vanguard section meant to overwrite our existing Guardians (Grand Advisors) Act?

I definitely support this overall, though. Admirable work.
Mini Profile Top
 
Lamb
Member Avatar

The Court has to have a minimum of three Prelates residing, so a vacancy implies lower than that. @Aumelodia

There's no reason to allow Guardians to decide whether or not an applicant supported by the rest of the region should reside along with them. Allowing that decision to be in the hands of only a few individuals, regardless of the trust in security we grant them, is not something I would like to see happen. There's currently no reason to change how our Guardians are appointed and I can only really see the negatives of implementing that change. Guardians, especially because of their high influence and endorsement counts in the region, should not be granted the potential to contradict the Cosmic Council's wishes, nor should they be battling each other with votes if there ends up being a divide. We grant those individuals the privilege to serve the region, not to tell us who we can grant that honor to.
Edited by Lamb, Jul 15 2017, 02:47 AM.
Mini Profile Top
 
Amerion
Member Avatar
Star Destroyer
@Doperland and @Kanglia

Thanks! ^_^

@The13th

Yes, I think the Legislative Procedures Act states that the Convenor may appoint deputies and shall rank them.

@Aumelodia

I've edited the proposal to include 'highest-ranked.'

The Line of Succession includes the Deputy Convenor as it is a guaranteed/official office in the Celestial Mandate Act. However, the specific language in the proposal is 'may' which indicates the Convenor may choose to do so. It does not necessitate that he/she must appoint a DC.

Yes, it is meant to overwrite the Act. It includes all the provisions of that Act but it amalgamates that Act with similar Acts.

Thanks ^_^

@Lamb

I've edited the proposal to strike that part.

Mini Profile Top
 
Aumelodia
Member Avatar
🌺 His Divine Eminence
Lamb
Jul 15 2017, 02:45 AM
The Court has to have a minimum of three Prelates residing, so a vacancy implies lower than that. @Aumelodia
In that case, the wording 'a prelate' makes no sense; 'Should the number of Prelates fall below three, a confirmation vote shall be held' would be more clear.
Mini Profile Top
 
Lamb
Member Avatar

Aumelodia
Jul 15 2017, 03:54 AM
Lamb
Jul 15 2017, 02:45 AM
The Court has to have a minimum of three Prelates residing, so a vacancy implies lower than that. @Aumelodia
In that case, the wording 'a prelate' makes no sense; 'Should the number of Prelates fall below three, a confirmation vote shall be held' would be more clear.
Yes.
Mini Profile Top
 
Drall
Member Avatar
Wildly Popular Scoundrel
The Line of Succession looks great, well done.
Mini Profile Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Cosmic Council Archive · Next Topic »
Image hosting by Photobucket
  • Pages:
  • 1


Theme by Sith - Recolored by Seth of Outline